1. Unilateral visa policy changes by the United States highlight the vulnerabilities of India’s skilled workforce abroad. Discuss the implications of such moves on India-U.S. relations, the Indian IT industry, and the welfare of the Indian diaspora. Suggest policy measures India can adopt to safeguard its interests.”
| Syllabus: General Studies – II: Effect of Policies and Politics of Developed and Developing Countries on India’s interests, Indian Diaspora |
The United States’ decision to impose a one-time $100,000 fee on fresh H-1B visa applicants, though clarified not to affect existing visa holders, underscores the uncertainties faced by India’s skilled workforce abroad. Such unilateral moves have far-reaching consequences for bilateral relations, the Indian IT industry, and the diaspora community.
Implications:
1. Bilateral Relations – Strains ties by projecting protectionist tendencies despite a “strategic partnership.”
2. Economic Impact – Indian IT firms face increased operational costs, reducing global competitiveness.
3. Employment Opportunities – Limits avenues for young skilled professionals seeking U.S. exposure.
4. Brain Drain Dynamics – Pushes talent to explore alternative destinations like Canada, EU, or Australia.
5. Diaspora Anxiety – Creates insecurity among Indians abroad, leading to rushed travel and financial losses.
6. Trade & WTO Angle – Raises concerns of discriminatory trade practices violating WTO principles.
7. Geopolitical Trust Deficit – India may perceive unpredictability in U.S. policy as undermining reliability.
Policy Measures:
1. Diplomatic Engagement – Use bilateral dialogues (e.g., India-U.S. 2+2) to seek exemptions or relaxations.
2. Diversify Destinations – Negotiate mobility pacts with Europe, Canada, and Asia-Pacific countries.
3. Strengthen Domestic Ecosystem – Promote “Digital India” and startups to absorb skilled professionals at home.
4. Global Advocacy – Use WTO or plurilateral forums to highlight discriminatory visa practices.
5. Bilateral Skill Partnerships – Develop training/certification frameworks recognized internationally.
6. Support Diaspora – Embassies and missions should extend proactive assistance to affected workers.
7. Strategic Bargaining – Link market access and tech collaboration with fair mobility arrangements.
The H-1B fee episode reveals how external policy shifts can unsettle India’s human capital and economic interests. A calibrated approach combining diplomacy, domestic reforms, and diaspora engagement is essential to safeguard India’s skilled workforce while ensuring that global talent mobility remains mutually beneficial.
| PYQ REFERENCE [2020] Q. ‘The Indian diaspora has a decisive role to play in the politics and economy of America and European Countries’. Comment with examples. [10 Marks] |
2) While low inflation benefits households, it poses challenges for government finances. Analyse how subdued inflation impacts nominal GDP, tax collections, and fiscal targets. Suggest measures to balance consumer welfare with fiscal stability.
| Syllabus: General Studies – III: Indian Economy and issues relating to Planning, Mobilization of Resources, Growth, Development and Employment. |
Low inflation is generally welcomed as it protects consumer purchasing power. However, when inflation remains below expectations, it reduces nominal GDP growth, thereby impacting the government’s fiscal arithmetic. India’s recent experience with CPI inflation around 2–2.5% and weak WPI inflation illustrates this dilemma.
Impacts of Low Inflation on Government Finances
1. Nominal GDP Growth – Lower inflation drags down nominal GDP even if real growth is robust.
2. Tax Collections – GST, excise, and income tax linked to production and profits rise slower with weak nominal growth.
3. Fiscal Deficit Ratio – As fiscal deficit is measured as % of nominal GDP, a lower denominator worsens fiscal math.
4. Debt-to-GDP Ratio – A slower rise in nominal GDP makes the debt ratio appear higher, straining fiscal sustainability.
5. Budget Targets – Revenue assumptions (e.g., ~11% tax growth in FY26) become unrealistic, forcing spending cuts or borrowing.
6. Investor Confidence – Missed targets may affect sovereign credit ratings and foreign investor sentiment.
7. Public Spending – Constrained revenues may limit capital expenditure on infrastructure and welfare schemes.
Way Forward
1. Realistic Budget Assumptions – Align nominal GDP projections with inflation trends.
2. Widen Tax Base – Strengthen GST compliance and expand direct tax net to reduce dependence on inflation-driven growth.
3. Counter-Cyclical Fiscal Policy – Increase capex during weak nominal growth phases to stimulate demand.
4. Boost Consumption & Investment – Incentivise private capex and wage growth to strengthen demand-side inflation.
5. Diversify Revenue Sources – Increase non-tax revenues via disinvestment, asset monetisation, and dividends.
6. Strengthen Fiscal Discipline – Rationalise subsidies and improve efficiency of government expenditure.
7. Collaborate with RBI – Ensure inflation remains within the target band (4±2%) to balance growth and fiscal stability.
Low inflation benefits households but challenges government finances by lowering nominal GDP and weakening tax collections. A calibrated approach — combining prudent fiscal management, realistic budgeting, and measures to sustain moderate inflation — is essential to safeguard both consumer welfare and fiscal stability.
| PYQ REFERENCE [2024] Q. What are the causes of persistent high food inflation in India? Comment on the effectiveness of the monetary policy of the RBI to control this type of inflation. [10 Marks] |