Amidst the recent scenario of rekindling of the Caste Census in India, critically analyze the sociopolitical significance and challenges of such an initiative in India.
Socio Economic Caste Census (SECC) in India:
SECC was first conducted in 1931 which aimed to collect information on the economic status of Indian families, both in rural and urban areas, to identify indicators of deprivation.
It also collects data on specific caste names to evaluate the economic conditions of different caste groups.
- Difference Between Census & SECC:
- Census provides a general portrait of the Indian population, while SECC is used to identify beneficiaries of state support.
- Census data is confidential under the Census Act of 1948, while personal information in SECC is open for use by government departments to grant or restrict benefits to households.
- Caste-based data collection has a long history in India, with information on castes being included upto 1931.
- Post 1951, the decision to stop collecting caste data was made to move away from a divisive approach and promote national unity.
- Significance of Caste Census
- By understanding the distribution of different caste groups, targeted policies can be implemented to address social inequality and uplift marginalized communities.
- Without accurate data on the population of OBCs and other groups, it is difficult to ensure equitable distribution of resources.
- A caste census can help monitor the implementation and outcomes of such policies, enabling policymakers to make informed decisions regarding their continuation and modification.
- A caste census can provide a comprehensive picture of the diversity of Indian society, shedding light on the social fabric and interplay between different caste groups. This data can contribute to a better understanding of social dynamics.
- Constitutional Mandate: Article 340 mandates the appointment of a commission to investigate the conditions of socially and educationally backward classes and make recommendations as to the steps that should be taken by governments.
- Legal framework regarding current green signalling:
- To include caste enumeration in the next Census, the government does not need to amend the Census Act. The Registrar General and Census Commissioner (RG&CC) is already empowered under existing law to design the census programme.
Challenges in implementing the Caste Census in India:
- Dilemma in choosing which list for the enumeration of OBCs: Since the centre and states maintain separate lists for OBCs in India which have significant differences between them, it requires huge political and good will in deciding which list to pursue.
- In the last Census, for SCs and STs, the proforma relied on the official lists notified under the Constitution (Scheduled Castes) Order, 1950, and the Constitution (Scheduled Tribes) Order, 1950. These lists — currently comprising 1,170 castes under SC and 890 communities under ST — are periodically updated through amendments passed by Parliament.
- However, for OBCs, there is no single, consolidated list. A central list maintained by the National Commission for Backward Classes (NCBC) is used for reservations in central government jobs and educational institutions. Separately, each state maintains its own OBC list, which often differs from the central list — and in many cases, includes many more communities.
- Procedural difficulties: The original 2021 Census was set to be the first to use digital enumeration, with enumerators collecting data via an electronic form rather than pen and paper. With the inclusion of caste data, the software will now need to be updated to include a new field for OBCs, along with a drop-down menu of sub-categories. Enumerators may face difficulties with new technology, but these can be addressed through proper training and rigorous piloting.
- Political challenges:
- The first decision is which list to use for OBC enumeration.
- But the far more consequential challenge will emerge after the data is published. Until now, reservation policies have relied on projections and estimates from the last caste census in 1931.
- The upcoming Census will offer the first accurate estimate of India’s caste composition in nearly a century.
- This data is expected to prompt demands for recalibrating reservation quotas in proportion to the actual OBC population—and could even fuel calls to lift the 51% cap on total reservations, set by the Supreme Court.
- Social challenges:
- Opponents of a caste census argue that caste-based discrimination is illegal and that a caste census would only reinforce the caste system. They argue equality should be enforced beyond caste based delimitations.
- Defining castes is a complex issue, as there are thousands of castes and sub-castes in India. A caste census would require a clear definition of castes, which is not an easy task.
- Might threaten social harmony due to surfacing of sensitive information.
- Possibility of spreading of misinformation and malinformation regarding Caste numbers in this era of social media.
Way forward:
- Equality, which is the ultimate goal, needs timely and accurate data for better planning and implementation of beneficiary programs. But so is peace and harmony.
- Any Caste Census should include provisions for Transparency, Responsibility, Sensitization, Data security and a pure notion of inclusive development.
- A Caste Census equally bearing the principles of Social justice and social harmony should be idealised.
Source: